Me Defending My Favourite Fictional Character: He's Not Even That Bad (meanwhile He Has A Literal Torture

Any other lit nerds out there always associate this quote with Erik?

“Pain and suffering are always inevitable for a large intelligence and a deep heart. The really great men must, I think, have great sadness on earth.”

Crime and Punishment, Fyodor Dostoyevsky

The Exterior Artwork on The Opera House

The Dance by Carpeaux —&— Lyrical Drama by Perraud

In celebration of the birthday of this most-beautiful building (a few days late, I know), I upload these photos I took on my recent visit to its majestic halls. Nowhere else have I seen such beauty nor felt such awe; it is a sanctuary for divine art and a fitting home for the Angel of Music.

Words cannot express my love for it, so I won’t even try.

Let me only say: Gaston Leroux NAILED its description in that book, both visually and atmospherically. That building IS Erik.

One great scene in Phantom of the Opera is in the torture chamber when Raoul and the Daroga hear Erik menacing Christine and first it sounds like she’s crying

- but it’s not her, it’s Erik full-on sobbing while he’s threatening her, and if that doesn’t describe his character perfectly what will

“The Phantom of the Opera really existed…”

The REAL People Behind Phantom of the Opera

I’ve always been into Phantom of the Opera and have always wondered if there was any truth behind Leroux’s story. Well, after some light research, I’ve found the real people who (possibly) inspired the characters in the story.

Christina Nilsson - Christine Daae

Probably the most well known within the phantom community, Christine Nilsson grew up in Sweden. She was born in 1843 and died 1921 and performed from 1860 - 1885. It was said she had a beautiful voice and was known for being “rivals” with Adelina Patti.

Adelina Patti - Carlotta Giudicelli

Adelina Patti was the first inspiration for Carlotta’s character. As stated before, she was the rival of Christina Nilsson. She was born 1843 and died 1919. Patti came from a family of musicians and performers and performed from 1869 - 1914.

Carlotta Patti - Carlotta Giudicelli

Carlotta Patti was the older sister of Adelina Patti and the inspiration for Carlotta Giudicelli’s name. There are various sources for her birthdate, stating it was either 1835, 1840, or 1842. She died in 1889.

Cecile Sorel - Sorelli

Cecile Sorel was born 1873 and died 1966. She began her career in 1899 and continued until 1944. She performed on stage as a comedy actress, but also appeared in a few French films during this time. In 1950 she took vows as a Third-order Franciscan.

Adelaide Valerius-Leuhusen - Mama Valerius

Adelaide was born either 1826 or 1828 and died 1923. She was a painter and concert singer and was also the benefactor of Christina Nilsson, being the first one to introduce her to Paris. In 1870, she became a singing teacher.

Mahomed Ismael-Khan - The Persian/Daroga

Mahomed Ismael-Khan was born somewhere around 1786 and died 1868. He settled in Paris in 1842 and was commonly noticed hanging out around the opera, where he kept the same box for himself. He was nicknamed “the Persian” by local Parisians.

Claude Ambroise Seurat - Erik

Possibly one of the inspirations for the opera ghost himself. Claude Ambroise Seurat was born either 1797 or 1798 and died somewhere around 1833. He toured around Europe and was known as “the living skeleton” or “the anatomical man” due to his very low body weight. People noted he had a parchment-like quality to his skin. His last recorded performance was in 1833, but he may have lived longer.

The Carpentiers de Changy - The Chagnys

The Carpentiers were possible inspirations for the Chagnys. While I wasn’t able to find definitive dates and names, I know a man named Francois was the inspiration for Philippe. Francois had a younger brother named Raoul who inspired… Raoul. There was also a young man a few generations later named Philippe, which is where the name came from.

Oddly enough, there was a young man named Eric Carpentier, though he never had the “de Changy” title. Some sources call him the son of Francois, others say he was born 3 generations after Francois. Either way. Eric was possibly an inspirations for Erik’s name in the novel.

Christine Dahe - Christine Daae

While this one isn’t as clear and is much less well known, there was a woman named Christine Dahe who was born in 1895. While Christina Nilsson was definitely the main inspiration for Christine Daae, you must admit that Dahe and Daae are very similar names, and Dahe may have inspired the name for Leroux’s character. She’s at the end of this list because this may just be a coincidence.

I hope you found this interesting, it’s so cool to think these people actually existed. If anyone knows more people who inspired the characters in the book, feel free to add them!

leroux style

The best of the best.

"Why, you love him! Your fear, your terror, all of that is just love and love of the most exquisite kind, the kind which people do not admit even to themselves." ... "The kind that gives you a thrill, when you think of it."

— The Phantom of the Opera, Gaston Leroux

Famous authors talking about Dostoevsky

Wh—….

….

ERIK?

It would be a lie to say I understood particularly much of the plot, but this figure from the opening ceremony of the Olympic Games in Paris 2024 was apparently the Phantom of the Opera.

*gasp* I love them

“Kissed her bruised and bleeding forehead”